Essay Instructions: Topic: the internet, virtual reality, and simulation.
Sources: Cynthia Freeland, But Is It Art? Chapter 7,
“Digitizing and Disseminating” and your own research on the web or in a library
Walter Benjamin, in a famous essay from the 1930s on “The Work of Art in the Age of Mechanical Reproduction,” predicted that the time was coming, or had already arrived, when the idea of a work of art as a unique object, as something endowed with an “aura,’ would give way to the idea of the work of art as something mechanically reproducible, as in the medium of photography or film. Benjamin thought this new kind of art would produce a new kind of audience with different organs of reception. If the new audience had a shorter attention span, it would also be receptive to different kinds of stimuli and to a different organization of those stimuli. In other words, new mediums would make not only make for new art but also for new kinds of experience of art.
After WWII Marshall McLuhan picked up on this idea with his suggestion that mass media would encourage “mosaic,” as opposed to linear, thinking. Television and the computer would break open the rule of textual logic by encouraging constellative thought: not one thing after another but rather several things at once, as when we watch a film or sit before a computer screen.
Finally, Jean Baudrillard comes in with the idea of the “hyperreal.” The hyperreal is an artificial, or simulated, appearance that comes to define reality. Not only is the medium the message, as McLuhan said, but the medium defines what the message is about. Freeland speaks of high fashion coming to define, not just illustrate, beauty. Other examples of this are the ways in which television, advertising, and popular music come to define “sex” and how reporting on a political campaign becomes a political event in its own right. Think of the practice of political “spinning,” or how managing the media’s reporting on elected officials, candidates, and issues has become an independent activity.
Essay. Describe in your own words Benjamin’s, McLuhan’s, and Baudrillard’s leading concepts, then ask yourself the following questions: to what extent has Benjamin’s and McLuhan’s dream been realized? To what extent was their dream a false promise? Put in another way, to what extent is Baudrillard’s concept of the hyperreal a critique of modern media? To what extent is it a celebration of the creative power of modern media? You should illustrate your analysis with examples or illustrations. These may take the form of an internet website, a film, a television program, or an entertainment site, e.g., DisneyWorld, Las Vegas.